Head to Head
MEATER Plus vs Instant-Read Thermometer: Which BBQ Thermometer Is Worth It?
The MEATER Plus costs $100. A solid instant-read costs $13. Both tell you when your meat is done. The question is whether app monitoring, no wires on the grill, and real-time ambient temperature tracking are worth the price gap. For some cooks, it's the best $100 they'll spend on BBQ gear. For others, the instant-read is all they'll ever need.
Option A
MEATER Plus Wireless Smart Meat Thermometer — 165ft Range
$99.95
Wireless thermometer with no wires on the grill. Monitors from your phone.
Option B
Instant-Read Digital BBQ Thermometer
$12.95
Reads in 2 seconds flat. Because real grillers don't guess.
Side by Side
| MEATER Plus Wireless | Instant-Read Digital BBQ | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $99.95 | $12.95 |
| Thermometer type | Wireless leave-in probe | Handheld instant-read |
| Measures ambient grill temp | Yes — dual sensor | No |
| Phone monitoring | Yes — app with alerts | No |
| Wireless range | 165ft Bluetooth | N/A — handheld use |
| Best cook type | Long, unattended cooks | Quick checks — steak, burgers |
| Battery | Rechargeable (24hr probe) | AAA — lasts years |
Best for
MEATER Plus Wireless Smart
- ✓Smoking brisket, ribs, pork shoulder — anything over 2 hours
- ✓Anyone who wants to monitor temp from inside the house
- ✓Cooks who want ambient grill temp alongside meat temp
- ✓Someone upgrading their BBQ setup to take it seriously
Best for
Instant-Read Digital BBQ Thermometer
- ✓Fast cooks — steaks, burgers, chicken breasts
- ✓Checking temp once before pulling the meat
- ✓Cooks on a budget who want accurate readings without the tech
- ✓A backup thermometer for quick verification
The Verdict
If you smoke meat — ribs, brisket, pork butts, whole chickens — the MEATER Plus is worth every dollar. You can run a 12-hour brisket and check progress from inside without ever lifting the lid. The ambient sensor means you know exactly what temperature you're cooking at, not just what the built-in dial says. The instant-read wins for fast cooks: you're not leaving a $100 probe in a steak for four minutes. The smart setup for serious BBQ guys is both — MEATER for long smokes, instant-read for verification and quick-cook checks.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the MEATER Plus worth the price?
For low-and-slow cooking, yes. The wireless design, app alerts, and dual-probe reading — meat temp plus ambient grill temp simultaneously — make a genuine difference on long cooks. If you mostly do quick grilling, an instant-read is all you need.
What's the difference between MEATER and MEATER Plus?
The MEATER Plus has a 165-foot Bluetooth range versus 33 feet on the original, and uses the charger as a Bluetooth signal extender for even longer range through walls. Worth the upgrade if you grill near obstacles or want to monitor from farther away.
Do you need a wireless thermometer for BBQ?
For low-and-slow smoking, a wireless probe is a genuine game changer — you're not babysitting a grill for 8 to 12 hours. For regular backyard grilling where you're standing at the grill anyway, an instant-read is plenty.
Can you use MEATER Plus on a gas grill?
Yes. The MEATER Plus works on any heat source — gas, charcoal, pellet, offset, or kamado. The probe clips to any grill grate with the ambient sensor sitting outside the meat.
SpangledStuff may earn a commission if you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. Product prices and availability may change — always verify on the retailer's page before purchasing. Learn more